Data from the credible transfer website Transfermarkt reveals that Bayern Munich is not among the top-spending clubs of the last decade.
In the list published by Transfermarkt, Bayern Munich, with a total expenditure of €1.14 billion, sits 17th on the list.
The top of the leaderboard is dominated by the Premier League big six, including Chelsea, Manchester United, Manchester City, Tottenham, Arsenal and Liverpool, as well as back-to-back Champions League winner Paris Saint-Germain.
La Liga's big three, Barcelona, Atletico Madrid and Real Madrid, also spent more money than Bayern in the last 10 years. There are some more surprising names in the top 15, namely Aston Villa, Newcastle United and West Ham United, three mid-table Premier League teams who have also had a decent amount of spending. West Ham is now in the Championship despite a €1.23 billion expspending €1.23 billion.
Some of the clubs which haven't seen adequate return on investment are Juventus and AC Milan, two fallen European giants struggling to regain their past glory.
Bayern Munich, on the other hand, has been able to maintain domestic dominance and European relevance with more moderate spending, considering the club's stature. Since the 2016/27 season, Bayern has won nine Bundesliga titles, one Champions League and a sextuple.
Smart and strict transfer policy
Bayern Munich prioritise value-for-money transfers instead of splashing big chunks of change on a superstar. Unlike many big clubs, the German record champion hasn't had a nine-figure signing, with Harry Kane being the most expensive arrival at €95 million.
Bayern's excellent scouting helps discover more hidden gems and bang-for-the-buck players. Michael Olise, now one of the best wingers in the world, was bought for only around €53 million. Tom Bischof, a top German talent, was scouted and persuaded to join the club on a free transfer.
The club's European-leading position also plays a big role. It improves Bayern's bargaining power thanks to the great interest from players. Bayern Munich is notorious for its harsh supervisory board members, who boast great power in financial decision-making.
One of the famous names on the board is Bayern Munich's honorary president, Uli Hoeness. He is known to be outspoken about the club's transfer policy and is generally active in the player recruitment process. He once told the newspaper kicker in 2017 that "a €100 million player is unacceptable" for Bayern Munich, and so far, it has remained true.
Sustainability is also one of the policies emphasised by the club in recent years. Bayern's first-team squad has several players promoted from the academy or brought to the club before turning 18, such as Lennart Karl, Aleksandar Pavlovic, Josip Stanisic and Jamal Musiala.
The club is also relatively strict about transfers that can bring negative value in the long run, such as players near or over the age of 30, even if they were in the prime of their careers.
Harry Kane is one of the odd ones out. He came to Munich when he was past 30 years old, but he has shown the highest calibre by breaking multiple records and winning the Ballon d'Or.
Transfer policy, not without mistakes for Bayern
Despite having an impressive "hit" rate when signing new players, mistakes are bound to happen. Sadio Mane, Joao Palhinha, Leroy Sane, and Lucas Hernandez are some examples of players who didn't live up to the hype in the past decade.
However, what saved Bayern from systematic failure from those poor signings was that the board tends to move quickly to dump the unnecessary players.
Mane and Palhinha were sold after one season for a reasonable cut. Sane and Hernandez's departure solved a bloated wage bill. This is why Bayern Munich can maintain a good balance despite being a top-20 spender of the last decade.
Is Bayern's board getting stingy?
This dataset also tells another aspect of the story. Bayern Munich is poor compared to other big clubs on the continent in terms of squad depth.
With an alarming number of injuries this year to Luis Diaz, Alphonso Davies, Serge Gnabry and Ismael Saibari, head coach Vincent Kompany has little to none to work with up front.
The situation makes what Max Eberl said earlier in the season echo even louder, when he claimed the squad is already adequate and wouldn't permit new signings. This winter transfer window must be used wisely to address the team's issues and the waves of backlash from the fans.
